The Stalking Horse Strategy: Testing the Waters for Strategic Success

Every decision bears weight in business, particularly in high-stakes environments like mergers and acquisitions (M&A), finance, and corporate negotiations. To mitigate risk while capitalising on opportunity, seasoned executives and investors sometimes employ a strategy known as the stalking horse. Far more than a covert tactic, the stalking horse is a calculated approach to test ideas, challenge competitors, or gauge market potential while minimising exposure. For C-Suite executives and investors, this strategy can be a powerful tool for protecting resources and maximising outcomes.

What Is a Stalking Horse?
Historical Origins of the Stalking Horse
Modern-Day Application of the Stalking Horse in Business
Stalking Horse in M&A and Bankruptcy Proceedings
Benefits of the Stalking Horse Strategy for C-Level Executives
Risks and Limitations
Case Studies: Real-World Examples of the Stalking Horse Strategy
Practical Considerations for Executives and Investors
Real-World Examples
Conclusion: Weighing the Impact of Stalking Horse Tactics

1. What Is a Stalking Horse?

A stalking horse refers to an entity or figure who presents an idea, bid, or proposal in public or within an organisation, testing its viability or gauging reaction on behalf of a third party. In cases where the idea is met with positive feedback, the third party, often the true party of interest, can move forward with confidence, avoiding the potential fallout of an unsuccessful launch or reception.

This approach serves a dual purpose: it allows the originating party to explore new ventures with reduced risk and provides a discreet avenue to gauge potential challenges or competitors. Particularly in competitive industries, stalking horse tactics enable companies to assess feasibility before significant investment or reputational risk.

2. Historical Origins of the Stalking Horse

The term originates from hunting, where a stalking horse (often an actual horse or decoy) was used to conceal hunters as they approached prey. In the corporate world, the principle remains largely the same; however, instead of prey, it is competitors, potential buyers, or stakeholders being observed or influenced indirectly.

3. Modern-Day Application of the Stalking Horse in Business

In the corporate arena, the stalking horse strategy has been adapted for a range of applications, including:

Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): Often, an initial bid by a stalking horse bidder sets the baseline in bankruptcy proceedings.
Product Testing: Companies may use third parties or ‘proxies’ to introduce new products, gauging market reception before formal release.
Competitive Analysis: For highly competitive markets, observing competitors’ responses to a stalking horse proposal can inform strategic adjustments.

These applications illustrate the versatility and value of stalking horse tactics in risk management, particularly where decisions can impact large-scale investments or brand reputation.

4. Stalking Horse in M&A and Bankruptcy Proceedings

In M&A, the stalking horse tactic is most visibly used in bankruptcy auctions. Here, the ‘stalking horse bid’ is an initial offer placed by a potential buyer to establish a base price for the company or asset being sold. This sets the competitive tone, ensuring the asset doesn’t sell for less than its worth, while also providing confidence to other bidders that a serious offer exists.

The Role of Stalking Horse Bidders

Stalking horse bidders are often offered certain protections, such as break-up fees, to compensate for the initial risk and cost they undertake. The potential advantages for stalking horse bidders include:

Lowered Competition: Acting as the first mover, they establish the base bid, which may deter less committed bidders.
Exclusivity Periods: They often gain initial negotiating privileges.

For investors, particularly those looking at distressed assets or complex acquisitions, the stalking horse bid process serves as a valuable framework for competitive advantage while safeguarding the company’s valuation.

5. Benefits of the Stalking Horse Strategy for C-Level Executives

For the C-Suite, adopting a stalking horse approach can align closely with key performance indicators (KPIs) and strategic objectives by:

Risk Mitigation: Testing the waters first, ensuring resources are allocated wisely.
Market Insight: Gathering data on customer sentiment and competitor moves without immediate commitment.
Resource Efficiency: Reducing expenditure and time on projects with less guaranteed success.

Through this strategy, executives can engage in proactive risk management, making better-informed decisions that are more likely to yield positive returns on investment (ROI).

6. Risks and Limitations

While the stalking horse strategy offers considerable advantages, it is not without limitations:

Loss of Control: The third-party nature of stalking horse bids can lead to unintended interpretations or responses from competitors.
Legal and Ethical Concerns: Depending on jurisdiction and market regulations, some elements of a stalking horse strategy may be subject to scrutiny, particularly if it involves market manipulation or misrepresentation.
Financial Costs: Though initially minimal, a stalking horse approach can still involve substantial resources if multiple rounds of testing are required.

7. Case Studies: Real-World Examples of the Stalking Horse Strategy

Case Study 1: General Motors’ Bankruptcy

In the 2009 General Motors bankruptcy, the United States Treasury acted as a stalking horse bidder, presenting an initial offer to establish a foundation for the restructuring process. This strategic move helped safeguard the company’s viability, ensuring competitive bids while managing public and stakeholder confidence.

Case Study 2: Kodak’s Patent Auction

When Kodak faced bankruptcy in 2012, it employed a stalking horse bid to sell off its digital imaging patents. This move ensured the patents were not undervalued in open bidding, ultimately leading to higher returns for creditors.

8. Practical Considerations for Executives and Investors

To harness the full potential of the stalking horse strategy, executives should:

Engage with Legal Teams: Ensure all aspects of the strategy comply with regulatory requirements.
Develop Exit Strategies: Be prepared with alternatives should the initial stalking horse approach not yield the desired outcome.
Utilise Data Analytics: Post-stalking horse analysis should involve a thorough review of market responses to refine future tactics.

9. Real-World Examples of Stalking Horse

Here are some well-known real-world examples where companies used the stalking horse strategy effectively, particularly in high-stakes mergers, acquisitions, and distressed asset sales:

1. General Motors (GM) Bankruptcy Auction

When General Motors filed for bankruptcy in 2009, the U.S. government acted as a stalking horse bidder to ensure GM’s assets would be preserved and the company could restructure. The Treasury’s bid helped anchor GM’s valuation, allowing for an orderly bidding process and preventing the company’s value from plummeting in the eyes of potential investors. By stepping in, the government encouraged other bidders to place competitive offers, helping GM eventually emerge from bankruptcy with a leaner and more sustainable business model.

Impact for GM:

This stalking horse bid was instrumental in giving GM a fresh start, helping protect thousands of jobs, and keeping the automaker afloat in a way that balanced both investor and public interests. It also underscored the role stalking horse bids can play in protecting company value during economic crises.

2. Kodak’s Patent Auction

Eastman Kodak, the photography pioneer, faced bankruptcy in 2012 and needed a viable way to generate funds for restructuring. The company initiated a stalking horse bid process for its digital imaging patents, allowing potential buyers to place initial bids under terms that would ensure competitive offers. By setting an initial bid through a consortium led by companies like Apple and Microsoft, Kodak created a benchmark, assuring creditors the patents wouldn’t be undervalued.

Impact for Kodak:

This move enabled Kodak to maximise the value of its intellectual property assets, raising nearly $500 million. The successful stalking horse bid not only brought essential funds but demonstrated how stalking horse strategies can effectively stabilise asset values under distressed conditions.

3. Toys “R” Us Bankruptcy Sale

When Toys “R” Us declared bankruptcy in 2017, the company sought a stalking horse bidder to maximise returns on its assets, especially for its Asian operations, which remained profitable compared to its U.S. operations. The stalking horse process established a base bid that attracted more interest in the assets. Bidders saw the value, eventually pushing the Asian unit’s sale price higher than the initial stalking horse bid.

Impact for Toys “R” Us:

This sale allowed Toys “R” Us to secure better returns on its Asian assets, providing critical funds during a time of insolvency. The strategy illustrated how stalking horse bids could attract competitive bidding, boosting the asset’s final sale value and benefitting creditors.

4. Sears Holdings Corporation Bankruptcy Auction

Sears Holdings, once a retail giant, filed for bankruptcy in 2018. The company’s chairman, Eddie Lampert, used his hedge fund, ESL Investments, to place a stalking horse bid for Sears’ remaining assets, including real estate and the iconic Sears brand. This bid set the base price, allowing Sears to stay operational while giving other bidders a chance to compete.

Impact for Sears:

The stalking horse bid allowed Sears to continue operations while a buyer was sought, preserving jobs and potentially maintaining some of Sears’ value. Ultimately, this approach gave Sears the breathing room to pursue alternatives that could offer creditors and stakeholders a better outcome.

5. American Apparel’s Bankruptcy and Stalking Horse Bid by Gildan

American Apparel filed for bankruptcy in 2016, with Gildan Activewear placing a stalking horse bid for the brand’s intellectual property and manufacturing equipment. This stalking horse bid set a floor price for American Apparel’s assets, ensuring the company’s legacy and intellectual property remained valuable.

Impact for American Apparel:

Gildan’s stalking horse bid laid the groundwork for an orderly auction, ensuring American Apparel’s brand value was preserved. The bid ultimately led to Gildan acquiring American Apparel’s brand assets, allowing the brand to continue its presence in the market under new ownership.

6. Hostess Brands’ Bankruptcy Restructuring

In 2012, Hostess Brands filed for bankruptcy, and two private equity firms, Apollo Global Management and Metropoulos & Co., placed stalking horse bids for its brands, including Twinkies and Wonder Bread. By setting initial bids, Hostess could draw other interested parties to ensure competitive pricing for these assets, enabling the highest possible return for creditors.

Impact for Hostess:

The stalking horse bids played a pivotal role in ensuring Hostess’s brands were not undervalued, resulting in a competitive auction that helped the company emerge from bankruptcy with new ownership and an opportunity for growth. Today, Hostess is once again a household name, largely thanks to this strategic sale process.

These cases illustrate the diverse applications and significant impact of stalking horse strategies in preserving corporate value, ensuring competitive asset pricing, and providing avenues for financially distressed companies to restructure or reposition their brands. For executives and investors, these examples highlight the critical advantages of stalking horse bids in high-stakes decision-making and market positioning, particularly in scenarios involving asset preservation, creditor interests, and long-term brand potential.

Here are some prominent real-world examples of the stalking horse strategy in India, where companies employed this tactic to secure assets, attract bidders, or test market interest, especially during distressed asset sales and bankruptcy auctions:

1. Essar Steel Bankruptcy Auction

Essar Steel, one of India’s leading steel companies, became insolvent in 2017, resulting in one of the country’s largest bankruptcy proceedings. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) allowed a stalking horse-style bid by ArcelorMittal, which set the base bid for Essar Steel’s assets. ArcelorMittal’s bid created a benchmark for other interested parties, ensuring the valuation remained competitive and attracting Nippon Steel as a co-bidder.

Impact for Essar Steel:

ArcelorMittal’s stalking horse approach helped establish Essar Steel’s value, ultimately allowing the company to be sold for over ₹42,000 crores (approx. $5.7 billion). The success of this bid demonstrated how India’s IBC reforms could facilitate stalking horse bidding, enabling distressed asset restructuring with minimal value erosion and ensuring higher returns for creditors.

2. Bhushan Steel Insolvency and Tata Steel’s Stalking Horse Bid

Bhushan Steel, another Indian steel major, entered insolvency proceedings in 2018. Tata Steel placed an initial stalking horse bid, creating a competitive base for Bhushan Steel’s assets. This initial offer brought other players like JSW Steel into the bidding process, further strengthening the final bid amounts.

Impact for Bhushan Steel:

Tata Steel’s stalking horse bid allowed Bhushan Steel to receive a substantial price of approximately ₹35,200 crores (around $4.8 billion), benefiting creditors and helping Tata Steel expand its operational footprint. This case highlighted the power of stalking horse bids to create competitive interest, preserving value even in distressed situations.

3. Ruchi Soya and Patanjali’s Stalking Horse Bid

Ruchi Soya, a significant edible oil and food product manufacturer, entered insolvency proceedings in 2017. Initially, Adani Wilmar made a bid, setting a base for further interest. However, Patanjali Ayurved, led by Baba Ramdev, subsequently placed a stalking horse bid, securing exclusive negotiation rights and eventually acquiring Ruchi Soya.

Impact for Ruchi Soya:

The stalking horse bid by Patanjali allowed Ruchi Soya’s valuation to increase to ₹4,350 crores (around $600 million). Patanjali’s acquisition reinvigorated Ruchi Soya’s business and kept the company’s well-known brands operational. This acquisition illustrated how a stalking horse bid can revitalise distressed assets and attract bidders in India’s competitive market.

4. Jet Airways Insolvency and Jalan-Kalrock Consortium’s Bid

Jet Airways, once India’s leading airline, ceased operations and entered insolvency in 2019. During the resolution process, the Jalan-Kalrock Consortium emerged as the stalking horse bidder, setting a base bid for Jet Airways’ assets and licenses. This bid prompted other bidders to evaluate the airline’s assets, although the Jalan-Kalrock Consortium ultimately won the bid.

Impact for Jet Airways:

The stalking horse bid ensured Jet Airways retained a competitive valuation, securing ₹1,000 crores in cash infusion and additional funds for operational revival. This case underscored the importance of a stalking horse bid in reviving iconic brands and attracting credible investors in complex and high-profile insolvency cases.

5. Videocon Group Insolvency and Twin Star’s Stalking Horse Bid

The Videocon Group, a conglomerate with interests in consumer electronics and oil, went into insolvency in 2018. Twin Star Technologies, a Vedanta Group company, placed a stalking horse bid to acquire Videocon’s oil and consumer electronics businesses. This base bid provided confidence to creditors and invited competitive offers.

Impact for Videocon:

The Twin Star bid, which was later increased following creditor demands, highlighted the value of Videocon’s assets and retained competitive tension in the bidding process. Though challenges arose regarding valuation concerns, the bid helped structure an organised sale for Videocon’s assets, illustrating the delicate balance required for stalking horse bids in distressed scenarios.

6. Lanco Infratech Insolvency and the Power Sector’s Stalking Horse Bid Interest

Lanco Infratech, a major player in infrastructure and power, entered insolvency proceedings in 2017. Power Finance Corporation (PFC) and Rural Electrification Corporation (REC) acted as stalking horse bidders, setting initial bids for Lanco’s power assets. This strategic move established a foundation, drawing additional interest from major players like NTPC and JSW Energy.

Impact for Lanco Infratech:

The stalking horse bids provided a baseline for Lanco’s asset valuation, ultimately aiding in the distribution of its assets to qualified buyers. By using a stalking horse bid, Lanco Infratech’s insolvency resolution process gained traction, ensuring critical assets in the power sector were preserved and aiding in India’s energy security.

These examples illustrate how the stalking horse approach is being integrated into India’s corporate restructuring processes, particularly under the IBC framework. For C-Suite executives and investors, these cases provide insight into how stalking horse bids can offer competitive advantages, stabilise asset values, and optimise outcomes for distressed assets.

10. Conclusion: Weighing the Impact of Stalking Horse Tactics

The stalking horse strategy can be a powerful means for C-Suite leaders and investors to navigate complex decisions, particularly where the stakes are high, and visibility is limited. By embracing this calculated approach, executives can gain a clearer understanding of market dynamics, competitor intentions, and the potential reception of new ideas—all while keeping risks manageable.

As markets grow increasingly competitive, the ability to test ideas discreetly yet effectively will only become more valuable. For those at the helm of organisations, mastering the nuances of the stalking horse strategy can unlock competitive advantages, improve decision-making confidence, and drive impactful, long-term success.

Table of Contents